
Rap Got Shut Out of the Grammys’ Big Three, and Don Toliver Is a “New Artist”
No rap in Album, Song or Record of the Year for the first time since 2013, while Don Toliver leads the genre with five nods, including Best New Artist.
AI-generated illustration
The 2027 Grammy nominations dropped on November 16, and the rap conversation started before the livestream even ended. Not because of who got in, but because of where rap did not show up at all.
For the first time since 2013, according to Billboard, no rap music is nominated for Album of the Year, Song of the Year or Record of the Year. Meanwhile British singer RAYE leads the whole field with 11 nominations and RosalĂa follows with nine, per the Recording Academy. On X, that combination set off two separate arguments at once: one about whether the Academy still knows what to do with rap, and another about whether “new” means anything anymore.

The “new artist” with five albums
Don Toliver is the most nominated rapper this cycle with five nods: Best Rap Album for Octane, Best Rap Performance for “Body,” Best Melodic Rap Performance and Best Rap Song for “E85,” and Best New Artist. That last one is where the timeline caught fire. As Stereogum pointed out, Octane is his fifth album.
The rules explain it. Rap Griot broke down how Best New Artist is meant to recognize a breakthrough into public consciousness during the eligibility period, not a recording debut. Artists need at least five singles or one album, with limits on past submissions and nominations. So on paper, Don qualifies. In the culture, plenty of fans who have been running his records since his Cactus Jack days still call it category fraud.
He is not slowing down to argue. Stereogum reports he announced a new album, Nitrous, for December 4, says he recorded, produced and engineered all of it himself, and is booked for his SNL debut the next night.
Who else is in the rap field
Cardi B and Doechii follow with four nominations each, per Rap Griot. Cardi’s Am I the Drama? is up for Best Rap Album, and “ErrTime” appears in both Best Rap Performance and Best Rap Song. Doechii’s “girl, get up.” with SZA is up in Melodic Rap Performance and Rap Song.
The full Best Rap Album list, from the official nominations: Busta Rhymes and J Dilla’s Dillagence II, Cardi B’s Am I the Drama?, Rapsody’s God Gotta Afro & Gold Hoops, Don Toliver’s Octane, Wale’s everything is a lot., and Kanye West’s Bully (Deluxe).
There are real wins in there. Billboard notes Wale picked up his first nominations since “Lotus Flower Bomb,” and Rap Griot points out Yung Miami earned her first ever nomination with “Spend Dat” in Best Rap Song. De La Soul and Nas share a Best Rap Performance nod for “Run It Back!!”
Our take
Rap does not need a gold gramophone to prove it runs the culture. Its fingerprints are all over pop, country and R&B right now, which is part of why Billboard called the shutout hard to believe. But the big three categories are where the Academy tells the mainstream what it considers important, and leaving rap out completely sends a message.
The silver lining is in the rap categories themselves. A list that includes Rapsody, a J Dilla collaboration, Wale and De La Soul next to Cardi and Don Toliver is one of the more balanced fields in years. Veterans, lyricists and hitmakers all made the cut. The Academy may be confused about the main stage, but in the genre categories, at least, it looked at the whole map.
Sources: Billboard, Recording Academy (announcement), Recording Academy (full list), NPR, Rap Griot, Stereogum.



